If you look hard enough, there's a lot of gold in the comments. Here is a selection of our favourite comments from 2021—some top rated comments and some gems that we thought went under appreciated. Enjoy!
Why wasn't the top comment on "Letter from the Editor: Pinkbike’s Next Chapter with Outside" added to the mix?
VtVolk (Jul 14, 2021 at 6:16) +2959 -26
"While our long term business model will evolve, a significant portion of our content will remain free." Welp, it's been a good run. Thanks for everything Pinkbike. I fear change and can only assume this is the end as we know it.
Because it's the editors favorite comments... Their opinion is above ours, we are idiots... I suggest they post a MOST liked comment by we the not so smart people of PB.
@simcik: There is a reason it's not top rated, as they are all negative comments about the takeover, which probably why this article tool so long, as they had to come up with something completely different
@Almostredbike: We like riding bikes and ragging on Outside for stickting their corporate fingers in our favourite grumble-about-the-industry-forum pie
The comment section response to the sale was way over the top, but not so sure it wouldn't have been better to own the upvoted comments rather than change the rules/criteria to get a different result. Regardless, hope the pinkbike crew is subjected to far less harassment than in 2021. Not their decision, and for the most part they've handled themselves very well through the whole thing.
You know what upset me the most about the outside buyout thing?
The fact that this comment became the most liked comment on Pinkbike. Taking that top spot from the comment that spawned the Stevie Smith memorial. I really liked that about Pinkbike.
Oh wow! That's hilarious! I haven't laughed that hard in a long time! Thanks for sharing. Definitely should have been one of the top comments, but I can see how most people wouldn't get it.
Wow, thanks for this honor! Nearly fifteen years as a PB commenter and I finally get the recognition I deserve. This is a day I'll always remember, like that day in nineteen ninety eight when the undertaker threw mankind off hell in a cell and plummeted sixteen feet through an announcer's table.
Haven't won shit in the PB holiday giveaway for several years in a row, and now even my comments aren't worthy...sigh. At least the people I keep tied up in my basement think I'm funny.....
Best one is the fest series comment. Still just trying to wrap my head around what darkfest was doing so differently, that other fest events were also doing, from a group of freeriders who participate in things like Rampage...
And the way of going about it. Instead of asking for revisions one on one or just each person opting out for personal reasons... A press release? Hard to tell if actually that out of touch or willingly chasing the reputation of being out of touch.
The only awards that matter in the bike industry.
I have my acceptance speech ready and my video setup ready to record for when this comment is in next year's list.
Here is my participation for the comments of the year 2022 - comment gold.
Have a nice ride my friends all other the world, stay healthy but please continue to crash every weeks to make my Friday better.
We need a poll on which is best. The evil ebike still makes me laugh as does the dauchsand (so?) one. Zocelli about the packs of feral golden doodles too Lolol.
It would obviously be a delete button. It would be pretty odd if moderation didn’t have that ability.
How they use it is the issue. I’ve seen at least one comment critical of Pinkbike disappear recently. It was super dumb, and I was about to make a counterpoint, but it still seemed pretty sketchy to be deleted. But if someone was posting off topic, hateful political content I would absolutely expect a mod to step in and remove it entirely.
@Blackhat: I would like them to delete such a comment, but I wouldn't expect them to delete it--based on past examples of exactly that being left un-deleted.
Hey PB, even after turning off news from Beta in my settings, why am I still seeing shit from Beta? I don't want to see the headline of something I can't actually read
I can very much relate to bigtim's experience with lockouts. Even a step further: I tend to notice that I locked out the shocks halfway back up, when I'm out of breath and only then realize why my bike was shitty on the downhill...
My most recent frame had complete internal tubing. Slid right through from entry to exit. Was actually faster to put together than external with zip ties.
How about a most downvoted list. Might actually have a shot at that list. No Trump joke too bad, no bike that doesn't look like a session. Puns that make no sense, outside+ joke anyone? That is my goal for 2022.
Can I please get at least 2000 upvotes on this boring comment just so that the comment gold article next year has to reference this really boring comment on this years comment gold? Go on, just hit that little green arrow....
VtVolk (Jul 14, 2021 at 6:16) +2959 -26
"While our long term business model will evolve, a significant portion of our content will remain free."
Welp, it's been a good run. Thanks for everything Pinkbike. I fear change and can only assume this is the end as we know it.
But apparently not enough to deflect us from what we're all thinking though.
The fact that this comment became the most liked comment on Pinkbike. Taking that top spot from the comment that spawned the Stevie Smith memorial. I really liked that about Pinkbike.
www.pinkbike.com/news/ineos-grenadiers-starts-a-mountain-bike-team-with-tom-pidcock.html
"Any word on what his brother, Stu, is up to?"
But was probably a bit too subtle to get noticed.
Iconic. Possibly the most excellent wrestling move of all time. Undefendable when executed correctly.
Trying to recall again what those were in 2021…
m.youtube.com/watch?v=Yb6dZ1IFlKc
* Terrible Puns
Things Pinkbike Editors don't like:
* Whinging About the Outside Takeover
And the way of going about it. Instead of asking for revisions one on one or just each person opting out for personal reasons... A press release? Hard to tell if actually that out of touch or willingly chasing the reputation of being out of touch.
How they use it is the issue. I’ve seen at least one comment critical of Pinkbike disappear recently. It was super dumb, and I was about to make a counterpoint, but it still seemed pretty sketchy to be deleted. But if someone was posting off topic, hateful political content I would absolutely expect a mod to step in and remove it entirely.
Outside: this is the way
Letter from the Editor: Pinkbike’s Next Chapter with Outside
quotes @mikelevy: I would def pay 50$ for this. PM me. No homo
You're welcome!